6ethics_paper_template_ xethicspaperrubric x
Ethics Paper
Directions
Select an ethical issue or dilemma
There are many ethical issues related to healthcare environments. Some of the ethical issues that occur in healthcare today are issues related to informed consent, organ donation, end-of- life care, truth-telling, palliative care, narcotic abuse, cultural care, spiritual care, privacy, and pain management. There are more! Select an ethical issue that has occurred in your current work setting or one where you previously have worked.
Literature search
Visit the APUS library. Conduct a literature search and find articles that pertain to the ethical issue/dilemma that you selected. Make sure your articles are scholarly and current. Sources must be within 3-5 years, of the current year, three years or less is preferred. Look for peer-reviewed articles/sources. You may also find additional references on the ANA website, or other professional websites. Six scholarly references are required.
Paper structure
Make the title page and reference sheet per APA format
The running head and page numbers correctly formatted
Double-spaced with 1-inch borders. Times New Roman Font 12 typeface is required.
The paper needs to meet the standards of professional writing in nursing, including accurate grammar, spelling, punctuation, and syntax. It must be in APA format.
There should be a minimum of six references. Three references must include the following:
The American Nurses Association Code of Ethics for Nurses, 2015,
The Kearney-Nunnery Advancing Your Career Textbook, and
The Park, Integrated
, 2012 article attached to this assignment.
Inclusions (see rubric for more details)
- Introduction
An overview of ethical issue/dilemma that occur in the profession and what will be discussed in your paper
- Describe one ethical issue/dilemma that happened in your workplace. Describe the ethical principles, e.g., beneficence, nonmaleficence, veracity, autonomy, justice, privacy, confidentiality, and fidelity that were not upheld. Identify and explain the Provisions of the Code of Ethics for Nurses that were breached, providing rationale for it being an ethical issue.
- Use the ethical decision-making model in the attached article to analyze the issue. Work through each step of the ethical decision-making model in detail to analyze the issue.
- Analyze how the ethical issue affected the patients/families and healthcare workers. Include a description of the varying viewpoints based on values, beliefs, and culture about the issue, and how you view the issue. Relate your personal ethical lens to your view.
- Describe how you think the issue should have been, or should be handled? Provide rationale. Make recommendations of how this issue can best be addressed in the future.
- Conclusion
Ethical Decision-making Model
The article entitled, “An Integrated Ethical Decision-making Model for Nurses” is attached below. Use the six steps of the model to analyze and guide your decision-making about the ethical issue that occurred in your workplace. Be sure to write about each step in your paper.
Use the Ethics Paper Template below to set up your paper.
See attachments below
1
Running head:
ETHICS PAPER
3
ETHICS PAPER
Ethics Paper
Author’s Name
Institution
Ethics Paper (Title of Your Paper)
Write an introduction, one to two paragraphs (not longer than one page), stating the major points of the paper. See APA 2.05 (p. 27) for guidance. The introduction should identify the a few ethical issues that are prevalent in healthcare that you found in the literature. Write one or two sentences explaining each issue. Introduce the ethical issue that has occurred in your work area. Write one or two sentences that explains this issue. Introduce the ethical decision-making model that will serve as the basis for this discussion of the ethical issue in your work setting. Don’t forget to cite appropriately.
Ethical Issue in Workplace
Discuss the actual ethical issue that has occurred in your work setting. Provide sufficient background so the issue is clear. Support the fact that this is an ethical issue, with references from your research. Use the ethical principles and the code of ethics to explain the rationale for it being an ethical issue. Limit this section to two to four paragraphs (one page).
Ethical Decision-Making Model
Discuss the decision-making model that you were provided in the directions for this assignment. Use this model to analyze your own ethical issue. Work through each step of the ethical decision-making model in detail, to analyze the ethical issue. Limit this section to two pages.
How Patients, Families, and Healthcare Workers are affected by the Issue
Describe how the ethical issue in your work place, affected the patient, family, and the healthcare workers who were involved in the issue. Include a description of the varying viewpoints based on values, beliefs and culture about the issue. Discuss how you view this issue. Relate your personal ethical lens to your view. Describe how you think the issue should have been handled. Provide a rationale for your answer. Make recommendations regarding how this issue can best be addressed in the future. Support your recommendations with findings from the literature. This is the only section that can be written in the first person. All other areas of the paper should be written in third person. This section should be no longer than one page.
Conclusion
The conclusion should be a summary of all of the main points in the paper. The conclusion should be one paragraph in length. Your paper is to be 6 pages in length, not including the title page and reference sheet. The running head and page numbers must be done correctly. It is to be double-spaced, and be written with Times New Roman, 12 font, and 1 inch borders. The paper needs to meet the standards of professional writing in nursing, including accurate grammar, spelling, and syntax. It must be in APA format. Please review the grading rubric for additional information.
References
Hawkins, S. F. & Morse, J. (2014). The praxis of courage as a foundation for care. Journal ofNursing Scholarship, 46(4), 263-270, doi10.1111/jnu.12077
Keele, R. (2011). Nursing research and evidence-based practice. Sudbury, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning
(Examples of correct format for an article and a book)
Ethics Paper Rubric
Beginning |
Developing |
Accomplished |
Exemplary |
Score |
Ethical Issue in the workplace (30%) Describes an ethical issue that has occurred in the workplace and the impact on patient/families and healthcare workers Analyzes ethical issue using ethical principles. Discusses Provisions of the Code of Ethics for Nurses, 2015 that were not upheld for this issue. |
Does not identify an ethical issue that has occurred in the workplace. Does not relate/minimally relates ethical principles to ethical issue. AND/OR No discussion of Code of Ethics for Nurses. 0-20 points |
Describesan ethical issue that has occurred in the workplace. Minimal analysis /minimal discussion of ethical principles. No discussion of Code of Ethics for Nurses. 21-23 points |
Describes an ethical issue that has occurred in the workplace. Analyzes of ethical issue using 2ethical principles. States a specific area of Code of Ethics for Nurses, 2015 that was not upheld for this issue. 24-27 points |
Thoroughly describesan ethical issue that has occurred in the workplace. Analyzes ethical issue using 3 or moreethical principles. Discusses Provisions of the Code of Ethics for Nurses, 2015 that were not upheld for this issue. 28-30 points |
Applies the Ethical Decision-making Model (25%) Use an ethical decision-making model to analyze the issue. Makes recommendations of how this issue can best be addressed in the future. |
Does not use the Integrated ethical-decision making toolto analyze the issue. Provides an incomplete analysis of the issue. Recommendation is brief, unclear, or does not represent an appropriate way to address the issue, OR no recommendation is present. 0-17 points |
Refers to the Integrated Ethical Decision-making model to analyze the issue. Misses analysis of some steps of the ethical decision-making model. No discussion provided. Makes 2 recommendations of how this issue can best be addressed in the future. 18-19 points |
Uses each step of the Integrated Ethical Decision-making model to analyze the issue with limited discussion of application to the issue. Provides 2 substantive recommendations of how this issue can best be addressed in the future. 20-21 points |
Writes each step and explicitly uses each step of the Integrated Ethical decision- making modelto thoroughly analyze the issue. Makes 3 substantive recommendations of how this issue can best be addressed and resolved in the future with rationale. 23-25 points |
Varying Points of View of Issue and Personal View (20%) Discusses varying viewpoints about ethical issues in the workplace. Include their values, beliefs and culture that affect their views. Discusses personal view of the issue and relates it to your PersonalEthical lens. |
Does not identify or minimally identifies varying viewpoints about the issue. OR Minimal/no description of the impact of ethical issue on patient/families, and healthcare workers. Does not discuss personal view or relate issue to the Personal Ethical Lens. 0-11 points |
Identifies varying viewpoints about the issue, and the impact on patient/families and healthcare workers. AND Identifies personal view of the issue but does not relate to the PersonalEthical Lens. 12-15 points |
Discusses varying viewpoints about theissue, and the impact on patient/families and healthcare workers AND Discussespersonal view of the issue and how it relates tothePersonalEthical Lens. 16-17 points |
Thoroughly discusses varying viewpoints about issue, and the impact on patient/families and healthcare workers. Include the values, beliefs and culture that affect the varying viewpoints. AND Discusses personal view of the issue and relates it to PersonalEthical Lens. 18-20 points |
Writing quality (10%) Communicates through writing that is concise, clear and logically organized Writes in complete sentences. No grammar, spelling, punctuation or syntax errors. Does not exceed the page limit. |
More than 3errors of any type. Exceeds page limit by 2 pages or more. 0-6 points |
3 errors of any type. Exceeds page limit by 1 page. 7 points |
No more than 2errors of any type. Does not exceed the page limit. 8 points |
No grammar, spelling, punctuation or syntax errors.
Writes logically in complete sentences. Does not exceed the page limit. 9-10 points |
APA format (10%) Correctly uses APA format in writing and citations. |
There are 5 or more APA format errors in the text, title page, in-text citations or reference page(s). Does not follow or partially follows template pattern. 0-6 points |
There are 3 -4 format errors in thetext, title page, in-text citations or reference page(s). Followstemplate pattern. 7 points |
There are 1-2 APA format errors in the text, title page, in-text citations or reference page(s). Follows template pattern. 8 points |
Text, title page, reference page(s), and in-text citations are consistent with APA format. Follows template pattern. 9-10 points |
Total 100 points |
Total Points Earned and Comments |
10/24/16